Comparing Texts - Practice

Grade 6 Reading | FL B.E.S.T. Standard: ELA.6.R.3.3
Name:
Date:
Directions: Read each pair of passages carefully. Then answer the questions comparing the texts. Remember to use evidence from BOTH passages in your responses!
Text A: "The Digital Revolution" (Informational Article)

The rise of smartphones and social media has fundamentally changed how young people communicate. Studies show that teens now spend an average of seven hours per day on screens. While technology offers benefits like instant communication and access to information, researchers warn about potential negative effects including decreased face-to-face interaction, sleep disruption, and increased anxiety.

Dr. Sarah Chen, a child psychologist, states, "We're seeing children who are brilliant at texting but struggle with basic conversation skills." Schools are implementing programs to teach digital literacy and encourage breaks from screens.

Text B: "Connected" (Personal Narrative)

When my family moved across the country, I thought I would lose all my friends forever. But my phone became a lifeline. Through video calls, I watched Maya's dance recital and helped Jake study for his math test. We started a group chat where we shared memes and inside jokes, keeping our friendship alive across 2,000 miles.

My mom worries I'm "always on that thing," but she doesn't see what I see - friends laughing together, supporting each other, staying connected despite the distance. Yes, I miss hugging them, but technology means I didn't have to say goodbye forever. Isn't that worth something?

Questions About Passage Pair 1

1. Both texts are about technology and young people. How do the GENRES of these texts differ?
2. How do the authors' PERSPECTIVES on technology differ?
3. Which author views technology more POSITIVELY? Use evidence from BOTH texts to support your answer.
4. What is one SIMILARITY between the two texts?
5. How does the FORMAT of each text affect how the reader receives the message? Why might an informational article versus a personal narrative have different impacts?
Text A: "The New Kid" (Short Story Excerpt)

Marcus stared at his lunch tray, pretending to be fascinated by his mystery meat. Three weeks at Jefferson Middle, and he still ate alone. Back in Detroit, he had known everyone. Here, the cliques were already formed, the friend groups sealed tight like fortresses.

"Is this seat taken?" A girl with bright orange sneakers stood beside him. "I'm Destiny. You're in my science class, right? You answered that question about gravity that stumped everyone else."

Marcus felt something loosen in his chest. Maybe fortresses had doors after all.

Text B: "Starting Over" (Short Story Excerpt)

Aisha clutched her schedule like a shield as she navigated the unfamiliar hallways. Beirut to Boston was more than miles - it was languages, customs, everything. Even the way students laughed sounded foreign.

In art class, she sat beside a boy who was sketching a dragon. "That's beautiful," she said, the English words feeling clumsy on her tongue.

He smiled. "Thanks. I'm Tyler. You new here?" When she nodded, he added, "Me too. Well, sort of - I moved here last year. It gets easier, I promise."

For the first time since arriving, Aisha smiled back.

Questions About Passage Pair 2

6. What THEME do both stories share?
7. How are Marcus's and Aisha's experiences SIMILAR? How are they DIFFERENT?
8. Both authors use the moment of connection with another student as a turning point. Compare HOW each author shows this moment.
9. The metaphor "fortresses had doors" in Text A and the phrase "It gets easier" in Text B both serve what purpose?
10. Imagine you had to write an essay comparing these two stories. What THREE elements would you focus on to show how the stories are similar and different?
Text A: Editorial - "Why Physical Education Should Be Required"

All students should be required to take physical education classes. Research shows that regular exercise improves concentration, reduces stress, and leads to better academic performance. The CDC reports that physically active students have better grades and attendance.

Some argue that students should choose their own classes, but childhood obesity rates have tripled in the past 40 years. Schools have a responsibility to establish healthy habits. Required PE ensures all students - not just athletes - get necessary physical activity.

Text B: Editorial - "Let Students Choose: The Case Against Mandatory PE"

Forcing all students into one-size-fits-all PE classes is outdated thinking. Students have different bodies, abilities, and interests. A student with asthma or social anxiety shouldn't be forced to run laps while classmates watch.

Instead of mandatory PE, schools should offer choices: yoga, swimming, dance, or even guided walks. Health education can teach nutrition and fitness without humiliation. Let's respect student autonomy and recognize that health looks different for everyone.

Questions About Passage Pair 3

11. What is the main DIFFERENCE in the authors' perspectives?
12. Both authors actually AGREE on something. What is it?
13. How does each author use EVIDENCE to support their argument?

Text A:

Text B:

14. Compare the TONE of each editorial. How does the author's word choice create different feelings in the reader?