Analyzing Arguments - Parent Activity Guide

Help your child become a critical thinker in a world full of persuasive messages

What is Your Child Learning?

Seventh graders are developing critical thinking skills for analyzing persuasive texts. They're learning to identify claims (main arguments), evaluate evidence (is it credible and relevant?), spot logical fallacies (flawed reasoning), and detect bias (one-sided perspectives). These skills are essential for navigating advertisements, news, social media, and everyday persuasion.

This is one of the most practical skills students learn - they'll use it every day when deciding what to believe and who to trust!

Key Vocabulary

Claim: The main point or position the author is arguing
Evidence: Facts, statistics, or expert opinions that support the claim
Logical Fallacy: An error in reasoning that weakens an argument (like "everyone's doing it!")
Bias: When an author favors one perspective without fairly considering others
Loaded Language: Words chosen to trigger emotions rather than logic (like "disastrous" vs. "challenging")

Activities to Try at Home

📺 Commercial Detective

While watching TV or videos together, analyze the commercials:

Why it helps: Ads are designed to persuade, making them perfect practice for spotting manipulation tactics.

📰 Two Sides Challenge

Pick a current debate (appropriate for your child) and find two articles with different perspectives:

Topics to try: School uniforms, later school start times, screen time limits, video games

🔍 Fallacy Finder

Learn to spot these common tricks in ads, social media, and everyday arguments:

Make it a game: Who can spot the most fallacies in a week?

💬 Family Debate Night

Practice building and analyzing arguments together:

Key rule: No personal attacks - critique the argument, not the arguer!

Questions to Ask About Any Persuasive Text

Parent Tip: Model Critical Thinking Out Loud

When you encounter persuasive content (a political ad, a product claim, a social media post), think out loud: "Hmm, that's an interesting claim. I wonder what evidence they have for that..." or "They're using a lot of emotional language - that makes me want to look more carefully at the actual facts." This models the thinking process you want your child to develop!

Common Logical Fallacies Cheat Sheet

Bandwagon

"Everyone's buying this!"
Popularity doesn't equal quality or truth.

Ad Hominem

"Don't listen to her - she's just a kid!"
Attacking the person, not their argument.

False Cause

"I wore lucky socks and won!"
Two things happening together doesn't mean one caused the other.

Either/Or

"You're either for us or against us!"
Pretending there are only two options when more exist.

Real-World Connection

Your child will use these skills constantly: evaluating product reviews, understanding news coverage, recognizing social media manipulation, making informed decisions about health claims, and eventually voting and civic participation. Learning to analyze arguments is learning to think independently!

Informacion para Padres (Spanish Summary)

Que esta aprendiendo su hijo? Los estudiantes de septimo grado aprenden a analizar argumentos:

Actividades en casa:

Preguntas para hacer:

Por que importa: Estas habilidades ayudan a los estudiantes a evaluar publicidad, noticias, redes sociales, y tomar decisiones informadas durante toda su vida.