The Gift That Keeps on Giving... Stress: Why Holiday Shopping Makes Us All a Little Loco
Last week, little Sofia asked me if I thought Santa would remember that her family moved apartments three times this year. My heart just about broke right there at the reading carpet.
Then yesterday, I overheard two of my students arguing about who was getting the new PlayStation for Christmas. One was bragging, the other went quiet and started picking at his shoelaces. That's when I knew we needed to talk about the elephant in the December classroom.
Holiday gift anxiety is real, y'all. And it's not just hitting our wallets. It's hitting our kids too.
The Pressure Cooker We've All Jumped Into
I've been teaching for 22 years, and I swear the gift pressure gets more intense every holiday season. Social media doesn't help. Neither do those toy commercials that start playing in October (seriously, who approved that timeline?).
But here's what I've learned from watching hundreds of families navigate December: the kids who remember their holidays fondly aren't the ones who got the most expensive gifts. They're the ones who felt the most loved.
Sounds cheesy, pero it's true.
When Money's Tight (And When Isn't It?)
Let's be honest about something. Teaching in Florida, especially at Title I schools like mine, means I work with families who are stretching every dollar until it screams. And even families with decent incomes are feeling the pinch with inflation hitting everything from groceries to gas.
If you're stressing about your gift budget, take a deep breath. You're not alone, and you're not failing your kids.
Here's what I tell the parents in my classroom community: your kids want your attention more than they want your Amazon cart.
The Stories That Stick
Last year, I asked my students to write about their favorite holiday memory. Want to know what they wrote about?
Marcus wrote about making cookies with his abuela and burning half the batch. They ate them anyway.
Camila's favorite memory was driving around looking at Christmas lights with her whole family crammed in their little Honda.
Isabella wrote three pages about the year her dad taught her to wrap presents and they used the Sunday comics because they ran out of wrapping paper.
Not one kid wrote about the expensive gift they got. Not one.
Shifting the Focus (Without Being Preachy)
I'm not going to tell you to skip gifts entirely. That's not realistic, and honestly, kids do love the excitement of unwrapping something special.
But we can shift the focus without making it feel like deprivation.
Try the "something you want, something you need, something to wear, something to read" approach. It naturally limits the gift pile while making sure everything has purpose.
Or do what my friend Carmen does: one big family gift that everyone can enjoy together. Last year it was a projector for backyard movie nights. Her kids still talk about it.
Teaching Kids About Gratitude (The Non-Eye-Roll Way)
This is tricky territory. Nobody wants to be the adult who kills Christmas magic with lectures about privilege.
But we can plant seeds.
In my classroom, we do "gratitude circles" in December. Each kid shares something they're thankful for that doesn't cost money. The responses always surprise me.
At home, try involving your kids in giving to others. Not in a "look how lucky you are" way, but in a "we can help our community" way. Let them pick out toys to donate or help you make cookies for neighbors.
When kids participate in giving, they naturally start thinking beyond their own wish lists.
Managing Your Own Holiday Anxiety
Ay, dios mio, we put so much pressure on ourselves to create perfect holidays. I used to stay up until midnight wrapping presents with color-coordinated ribbons like I was competing in some invisible Pinterest contest.
Then one year, my daughter Daniela told me her favorite part of Christmas morning wasn't the gifts. It was how happy and relaxed I seemed before everyone else woke up, drinking my coffee and watching the sunrise.
That hit me hard.
Our kids pick up on our stress more than we realize. When we're anxious about money or gifts or creating perfect moments, they feel it.
So this year, I'm giving myself permission to do less. Fewer decorations. Simpler meals. More sitting together on the couch watching terrible holiday movies.
Practical Tips That Actually Work
Here are some strategies that have worked for families in my classroom:
Start a new tradition that costs nothing. Maybe it's reading the same holiday book every year, or taking a walk to look at neighborhood decorations, or having breakfast for dinner on Christmas Eve.
Make gifts instead of buying them. I know, I know, you're already overwhelmed. But kids love handmade stuff. Photo albums, painted rocks, homemade playdough in fancy containers. Simple works.
Set clear expectations early. If this is going to be a smaller Christmas, tell your kids ahead of time. Most children are more adaptable than we give them credit for.
Focus on experiences over things. A special outing, a camping trip in the living room, a day where kids get to plan all the family activities. These create the memories that stick.
The Real Gift
Here's what I want you to remember: your presence is the present. I know it sounds like something on a coffee mug, but it's true.
Your kids won't remember if their gifts came from Target or Amazon or the dollar store. They'll remember if you were stressed and distracted or if you were present and enjoying the moment with them.
They'll remember if you laughed when the wrapping paper ran out, or if you got creative with newspaper and ribbon.
They'll remember the feeling in the house more than what was under the tree.
Moving Forward Without the Guilt
This holiday season, let's make a pact. Let's stop apologizing for not doing enough, not spending enough, not being enough.
Let's stop comparing our December to everyone else's highlight reel.
Let's remember that some of the most magical holiday moments happen when plans go sideways and we roll with it together.
Your kids don't need a perfect Christmas. They need a real one, with parents who are present and families who love each other, stress and all.
Take a deep breath, mija. You've got this. And your kids are lucky to have you, regardless of what's under the tree.
Maria Santos
Maria has been teaching 4th grade in Tampa, Florida for 22 years. Known as "the math whisperer" among her colleagues, she writes about the real challenges and victories of teaching in Florida's public schools.
When she's not grading papers or creating lesson plans, you can find Maria at her local teacher supply store (with coupons in hand) or sharing teaching tips over cafecito with her teacher friends.
View Full Profile →Related Articles
The Parent Email Template That Changed Everything
Parent communication tip: Picture this: It's 7:30 PM on a Tuesday, and I'm sitting at my kitchen tab...
Conference Prep That Actually Works (And Won't Keep You Up All Night)
Parent communication tip: Last Tuesday, I watched my colleague Jessica frantically shuffling through...
Ready to Improve Your FAST Scores?
Upload your class data and get personalized IXL success plans in seconds.
Try It Free