When September Reality Hits: Surviving the Honeymoon Hangover
It's 7:30 AM on a Tuesday in late September, and little Jayden just announced to the entire class that his mom's boyfriend moved out last night and took the Xbox. Sarah forgot her homework for the third time this week. And somehow, despite spending my entire August paycheck at Target, I'm already out of glue sticks.
Welcome to September reality, friends.
You know what I'm talking about. Those first few weeks of school when everything felt possible? When your bulletin boards were pristine and your behavior chart actually worked? When you thought, "This is going to be MY year"?
Yeah, that honeymoon period is officially over.
The Crash Is Normal (And Necessary)
After 22 years in the classroom, I can tell you that September reality hits every single teacher. Even the ones who look like they have it all together on Instagram. Trust me, behind those perfectly organized classroom photos is probably a teacher who cried in her car yesterday because nothing went according to plan.
I remember my third year teaching, I was so discouraged by October that I seriously considered switching careers. My classroom management was falling apart, my lesson plans felt boring, and I was convinced I was failing my kids.
My mentor teacher, Mrs. Rodriguez, sat me down and said something I'll never forget: "Mija, August is about hope. September is about reality. October is when the real teaching begins."
She was right.
Why September Feels So Hard
Here's the thing nobody tells you in teacher prep programs. Those first few weeks aren't real teaching. They're performance art.
Kids are on their best behavior because everything is new. Parents are still checking homework every night. Everyone's trying to make a good impression.
But by late September? The novelty has worn off. Kids start testing boundaries. Real life creeps in. That student who seemed so eager in August reveals they're actually struggling with anxiety. The quiet one in the back corner finally feels safe enough to show their true personality (which happens to be class clown).
This isn't failure. This is when authentic relationships begin.
Adjusting Your Expectations (Without Lowering Standards)
The first thing I do when September reality hits is take a hard look at what's actually working and what needs to change.
That elaborate behavior system I spent hours creating? If kids aren't buying into it, it's time to simplify. Last year, I scrapped my complicated point system in October and switched to something much simpler. The kids responded better, and I stopped spending my lunch breaks calculating points.
Those Pinterest-worthy bulletin boards? They can wait. Your sanity cannot.
I've learned to be flexible with my plans while keeping my standards high. Yes, I still expect respect and effort. But maybe that means adjusting how I teach certain concepts or changing my classroom routines.
Small Fixes That Make a Big Difference
Sometimes September feels overwhelming because we think we need to overhaul everything. But often, tiny tweaks can shift the entire energy of your classroom.
Morning routines matter more than you think. If your mornings are chaotic, everything else feels harder. I started playing soft music and having a simple brain teaser on the board. Nothing fancy, but it gives kids something to focus on while I handle the inevitable morning crises.
Check in with your challenging students privately. That kid who's been acting out? Pull them aside and ask how they're really doing. Sometimes behavior issues are just unmet needs in disguise.
Celebrate the small wins. When Marcus finally turned in his math homework without being reminded, I made sure to acknowledge it quietly. When the whole class transitioned to carpet time without chaos, we took a moment to recognize it.
The Power of Starting Over
Here's something I wish someone had told me years ago: you can start over anytime you want.
You don't have to wait until Monday. You don't need a new semester. If something isn't working, change it tomorrow.
I once completely restructured my reading groups in the middle of October because I realized my original setup wasn't serving my kids. Did it feel weird to essentially restart? A little. But it was so much better for everyone involved.
Your students won't think less of you for admitting something isn't working. In fact, they'll respect your honesty and flexibility.
Taking Care of Yourself in the Chaos
When September reality hits, we often forget to take care of ourselves. But here's the truth: you cannot pour from an empty cup, and your students need you at your best.
This means saying no to that extra committee (yes, even in September). It means ordering pizza for dinner instead of cooking from scratch. It means asking for help when you need it.
Last week, I was drowning in data analysis and my colleague Yolanda offered to help. Old me would have said, "No, I've got it," and stayed until 7 PM. New me said, "Yes, please," and went home in time to help Marcus with his algebra homework.
Finding Your Rhythm Again
The good news about September reality? It's temporary.
By October, you'll find your rhythm. You'll know which students need extra check-ins and which ones thrive with independence. You'll figure out that teaching fractions right after lunch is a disaster, but first thing in the morning works perfectly.
Your classroom will start to feel like home again, just a different version than you imagined in August.
Remember Why You're Here
On those really tough September days, when nothing goes right and you question everything, remember this: you're exactly where you need to be.
Those kids who are driving you crazy? They need you most. That lesson that flopped completely? It's teaching you something important about your students.
We didn't become teachers because it was easy. We became teachers because we believe in the power of education to change lives. Some days that looks like perfect lesson plans and engaged students. Other days it looks like being a safe adult for a kid whose world is falling apart.
Both matter equally.
So if you're reading this while hiding in your classroom during lunch, wondering if you're cut out for this, let me tell you: you are. September reality is hard, pero we're harder.
Take a deep breath, adjust what needs adjusting, and keep going. Your October self will thank you.
And remember, we're all figuring this out together, one day at a time.
Maria Santos
Maria has been teaching 4th grade in Tampa, Florida for 22 years. Known as "the math whisperer" among her colleagues, she writes about the real challenges and victories of teaching in Florida's public schools.
When she's not grading papers or creating lesson plans, you can find Maria at her local teacher supply store (with coupons in hand) or sharing teaching tips over cafecito with her teacher friends.
View Full Profile →Related Articles
The Calm Corner: Worth the Classroom Real Estate
Classroom management tip: Last Tuesday, I watched Miguel transform from a hurricane of frustration i...
The January Struggle is Real: Getting Your Classroom Back on Track After Winter Break
Classroom management tip: Last Tuesday, little Marcus (not my son, my student Marcus) raised his han...
Ready to Improve Your FAST Scores?
Upload your class data and get personalized IXL success plans in seconds.
Try It Free